There's a saying that pioneers tend to come back stuck full of arrows. After a couple of days trying to get Redis working with PHP, I know that feeling!
I'm successfully using Tokyo Tyrant/Cabinet for my key/value store, but I do find for a lot of my uses disk access is a major bottleneck on performance. I do lots of application-level RAM caching to work around this, but Redis's philosophy of keeping everything in main memory looked like a much lower-maintenance solution.
Getting started is simple, on OS X I was able to simply download the stable 1.02 source, make and then run the default redis-server executable. Its interface is through a TCP socket, so I then grabbed the native PHP module from the project's front page and started running some tests.
The first problem I hit was that the PHP interface silently failed whenever a value longer than 1024 characters was set. Looking into the source of the module, it was using fixed-length C arrays (they were even local stack variables with pointers returned from leaf functions!) and failing to check if the passed-in arguments were longer. This took me an hour or two to figure out in unfamiliar code, so I was a bit annoyed that there weren't more 'danger! untested!' signs around the module, though the README did state it was experimental.
Happily a couple of other developers had already run into this problem, and once I brought up the issue on the mailing list, Nicolas Favre-Félix and Nasreddine Bouafif made their fork of PHPRedis available with bug fixes for this and a lot of other issues.
The next day I downloaded and ran the updated version. This time I was able to get a lot further, but on my real data runs I was seeing intermittent empty string being returned for keys which should have had values. This was tough to track down, and even when I uncovered the underlying cause it didn't make any sense. It happened seemingly at random, and I wasn't able to reproduce it in a simple test case. An email to the list didn't get any response, so the following day I heavily instrumented the PHP interface module to understand what was going wrong.
Finally I spotted a pattern. The command before the one that returned an empty string was always
<1000 character-long value>
It turned out that some digit-counting code thought the number 1000 only had three digits, and truncated it to 100. The other 900 characters in the value remained in the buffer and were misinterpreted as a second command. That meant the real next command received a -ERR result. I coded up a fix and submitted a patch, and now it seems to be working at last.
Hitting this many problems so quickly has certainly made me hesitate to move forward using Redis in PHP. It's definitely not a well-trodden path, and while the list was able bring me a solution to my first problem, I was left to debug the second one on my own, and a question about Unix domain sockets versus TCP was left unanswered as well. If you are looking at Redis yourself in PHP, make sure you're mentally prepared for something pretty experimental, and don't count on much hand-holding from the developer community.
Of course, the same goes for almost any key/value store right now, it's the wild west out there compared to the stability of the SQL world. My next stop will be MongoDB to see if having a well-supported company behind the product improves the experience.